April 29, 2008 - 7:37am — Lenelle Moïse
I spent my undergraduate years at Ithaca College in central New York, a liberal arts school famous for its state-of-the-art music conservatory. I studied women and theatre and film there but became acquainted with a young classical
composer — let's call him Lyle.
Lyle came from money. His mother had been an opera singer, and his father did something or another for some corporation or another. They rented him a fancy multi-level apartment, off-campus. It had wall-to-wall white carpet, a
songwriting nook and a plush loft bed. Lyle lived alone, but wooed a lot of ladies in that coveted apartment. He tried
to woo me, but what can I say?
I'm gay.
Still, we managed to be friends. Good friends, even. We sang jazz standards together, held spontaneous cart-wheel
competitions on the Ithaca Commons and occasionally met for breakfast to have lengthy, animated conversations
about liberal politics, Western Buddhism and high art. One morning, Lyle confided that he was nervous about an
upcoming concert. As part of his midterm exams at the conservatory, he told me, he was called to conduct a 20-piece classical orchestra.
"I never really got the conductor thing," I confessed. "I mean, the musicians already have their sheet music. Why do
they need some white dude in a black tuxedo wildly waving his arms at them when they're trying to perform?" It was
an earnest question.
If Lyle had been wearing pearls, he would have clutched them. He was genuinely appalled. Down-right aghast. It was
as if I had said I was pregnant with quintuplets or that I planned to vote Republican. His cheeks flushed bright red.
"You're a theatre artist, you should know better," he yelled across the table. "Actors have scripts and memorize lines,
but have you ever staged a play without a director?"
Lyle had a point. But damn. Did he have to raise his voice? Even if I had asked a stupid question, did I deserve to be
publicly humiliated for my ignorance?
I grew up in the socioeconomically diverse ci.ty of Cambridge, Mass, home to the smart asses who go to
Harvard and MIT. It was also an environment that encouraged me and my peers to ask "stupid questions."
Cambridge boasted just one public high school. Young people of color represented 60% of the student body.
When you walked into our giant gymnasium, 70 flags of the countries of students' origins were flaunted
overhead. My diverse group of friends included Joanne from the Dominican Republic, Malik from West Philly, Chara
from Liberia, Semhar from Eritrea, Desiree from Trinidad, Mario from Greece, Chris from Cape Verde and Kubhear from
Malaysia. Aminah was Indian, but adopted by white parents, and there were many other multiracial, hyphenated, new
and complicated Americans.
I went to high school in the 1990s, when feminism moved into the binary-busting Third Wave, when queers became queer theorists and when MTV made an unprecedented effort to diversify its programming. Gone were the '80s when sexist rock-n-rollers dominated the small music video screen. And we weren't yet in the 2000s when corny boy bands and materialistic, misogynist mainstream hip hop dominate pop radio. My well-rounded group of friends knew the lyrics
to Arrested Development's "Tennessee," Lisa Loeb's "Stay" and songs by Sinead O'Connor, Salt N Pepa, Fiona Apple,
Kirk Franklin and, God help us, Snoop Dogg. We defied popular stereotypes: I knew white kids who could dance,
black kids who loved mosh pits and Latinas who didn't speak Spanish. I was in an acting class with a governor's
daughter. She lived in a mansion. I lived in the projects. But in our baggy jeans, baby doll dresses, construction boots and bright blazers, my "Cantabridgian" classmates felt as hip as we were.
We also asked each other a lot of basic — even base — questions:
"What the hell is Hanukkah?"
"Where in the world is Eritrea?"
"How do you say 'tap that ass' in Portuguese?"
"Do Greek people still wear togas?
We were young. We were hormonal. We were brazen. We were crude. We were the poster children for integration. For
better or for worse, we were each other's cultural ambassadors. We understood that we would never learn anything if we never asked anything.
Not every question was easy on the ear. As a Haitian-American, I did not enjoy being asked if I came to the United States on a boat, for example. But, in the spirit of coexistence, I practiced patience when an otherwise intelligent friend inevitably displayed their ignorance. Usually, I indulged them by sincerely answering the disturbing question. Then I followed up with "I find your question offensive because..."
Oftentimes, a lively debate ensued. We either came to an agreement or agreed to disagree, then went back to talking
about what crazy Jim Carrey did on In Living Color the night before.
I missed Cambridge when Lyle berated me for not knowing how important conductors were. I miss Cambridge a lot. Some of the wisest people I know are PEOPLE WHO KNOW THEY DON'T KNOW.
30 Comments
i always wanted to know in
i always wanted to know in what way the conductor was usefull for people who knew exactly what to do ... but i actually like to see them wave !lol i think its cute they look so serious doing it!
when i was a kid i used to listen to classical music and pretend to be a conductor , with my mom's chinese sticks! stupid !lol
i hate stupid questions when they re offensive , just like the one you took as example about hatian coming from boats !
people asked if if where i live ( in the caribbean ) we had cars or if we used elephants...
and of course as a lesbian you get the
" who's doing the man ? her or you ?"
" if you re a lesbian ,then it means you dont like boys right ? "
" oh, you re gay! so you dont want children?"
of course everyone ask stupid questions and its normal beause we dont know everything , but some of these stupid questions can be pretty offensives and people should really think twice before they open their damn mouth !
Sa ki la pou'w dlo pa ka chayé'y
No stupid questions
I've never learned so much as when I'm tried to answer a stupid quesion. ATK
I feel like I know you. Did
I feel like I know you. Did we go to high school together? *sigh* the integration generation. It's a wonderful thing.
I graduated in '90 and I remember class mates of mine who wore T's saying "it's a black thing, you wouldn't understand" - and then all of a sudden you'd see these T's popping up saying "it's an Irish thing,..." and "It's a German thing,..." and "It's a Puerto Rican thing,..."
I swear if it wasn't for music or sports or the arts, my school would have been heavily segregated in it's walls. And the camaraderie that takes place being in these group activities - are extremely important in the bridging.
There's a new series on PBS, called Carrier. This weeks episode, had two sailors being discharged - because of racist mentality that was a thorn to the ship and Navy. But before the discharge, I viewed one gentleman trying to bridge to stop that mentality. I had tears in my eyes. Camaraderie. Living change makes a difference.
rovermom :)
Life is a 3D puzzle and everyone has a piece!
NEW! OurChart Photo Assignment and My Blog
Yes!
Your blog reminds me of Socrates, who believed that the greatest truth was knowing that one knows nothing.
Tap that ass in portuguese
Tap that ass in portuguese sounds like "bater nesse rabo" btw :)
On stupid questions
I wore a big metal brace on the outside of my clothes for years. I also wore a big plastic one that was concealed under my clothes for a time before the metal one and following the body cast (in which I did not really go out much...). I was 14 when my family was in the car crash that fractured my spine and kicked off all of this fun.
In the plastic, not-so-obvious brace, people sometimes stared at my oddly-shaped torso, and most of the time some level of my consciousness was perseverating on how weird I must look to everyone, and would they really think I'm a robot-shaped girl? I had been athletic and powerful, and now I was broken and being held up by platic and Velcro. Not quite, but it felt that way sometimes, and I was self-conscious of what others thought but didn't say.
When I ended up back in the brace (no pun intended), but this time in titanium form, it wasn't constructed in a way that encouraged wearing under clothes. The latch tore through many a jacket, in fact. So I wore it on the outside. Fortunately, I was now in college and less concerned with what the rest of the world thought of me. Many, many times every day, random strangers walked up to me and asked what would here be considered a stupid question (or at least an offensive one): "What happened to you?" Little kids reached out to touch it, but adults just stared and blurted out some version of this question. Sometimes, someone would actually come up and say, "I had to wear that for scoliosis! What's your story?" That wasn't so bad. The truth is, this didn't bother me as much as you would think. Sometimes I felt like a tape recorder on playback: I broke my back in a car crash when I was 14...No, I don't sleep in it...Yes, it's uncomfortable, but it's worse when I don't have it on....
Once, while I was walking with my boyfriend in some mall in Ithaca (Lenelle: He went to Cornell, not Ithaca College, but isn't it just gorges?), he almost started a fight with a rude onlooker. Fact was, the frustrated boyfriend was recovering from knee surgery. Here he was, hobbling around on crutches with this monster of a full-leg brace, and people were staring unabashedly at me in my much more out-of-the ordinary titanium brace. So, one rubber-necker got an angry shake of the crutches and I dragged the boy along to whatever movie we were off to see.
Truth is, I didn't even notice the stares anymore, but had I, I would've preferred the questions. Answering them was a chance to show someone that people who appear different aren't freaks, and an exercise in patience that has helped me deal with people of all sorts every day of my life. It taught me how to consider the perspective of the person asking, and answer honestly in the simplest way possible. It helped me explain bone cancer to an 8-year-old who had never heard the word before his diagnosis. It helps me politely educate ignorant people about what it means to be a lesbian. It helps me explain complicated medical procedures/concepts to confused, tired, terrified parents in a way that they can actually understand. It helps me use my Spanish vocabulary to the greatest advantage in explaining these things to my non-English speaking latino patients. It may help prevent me from being sued by my most irrational, out-of-control, toxic family who will sue the rest of our hospital, I am convinced.
Lenelle, we all need to look to your adolescent experience and capture that spirit of patience and understanding, where answering a stupid question is not insulting or just beneath us, but rather a simple human decency owed to the person honest enough to ask.
~paz y amor siempre
Great Blog
Sometimes I ask some stupid questions... but my mom always says "It is better to be stupid for a minute, than be stupid for the rest of your life"
But the way, "Tap that ass" in Portuguese does not sounds very nice...LOL
Momma knows best
I like your mom's thought process!
~paz y amor siempre
Always asked stupid questions -
like: when I was 19 "Pickles are cucumbers, aren't they?!?!" just the other day here on OC "What the ding whing is a Cougar?" my first love "You do what to that?!?!"
I've been very lucky that those around me have been most accommodating with sympathetic awe to my ignorance.
and Orchestra Directors? Even players need direction! ;)
Nothing but love
Tex
Great!
Diversity is a wonderful thing and makes the world such an interesting place. The best way to kill stereo types is to ask "stupid" questions. May we keep on asking these!
Loved your blog.
sarah4annah
How Dare You?
Oh, if ONLY stupid questions were allowed and honest, uninsulted answers given - dropping cynicism and presumption. Utopia!
I so appreciate your blogs Lenelle. :)
Stupid Questions
I tell my students that there are no stupid questions. Stupidity exists when you fail to ask for information that you need.
I've wondered that too
Well, I've wondered why orchestras needed conductors. Your pal had a good explanation but ruined it by yelling and saying you should have known better.
Now, how do you say "tap that ass" in Portuguese?
there is a sanskrit
aphorism that goes something like:
to know is to know not, to know not is to know.
Kell McCartney will have to correct me on that one.
...
"yasya amatam tasya matam; matam yasya na veda sah" - he of whom there is no thought, there is knowledge; he of whom there is thought is not a Knower.
(mata come from the word to think, in a more intellectual sense. veda comes from the word to know, a deeper sense of understanding.)
Okay
i know who you are you sassy kid...
:-)
tee hee
Except...
she had to consult with her left brain to figure it out.
yup. i am absolutely stuck
yup. i am absolutely stuck in the left brain right now. sigh. (hi kelly)
there you go again...
being a wise ass...
p.s. and what would i do with out you, left brain?
holy cow,
brahma and vishnu, where did you come from?
Kell McCartney......
....that woman has beautiful blue eyes!!!!
Nothing but love
Tex
aww shucks, ma'am.
aww shucks, ma'am.
are you know
flirtin' with everyone here? I'm gonna start gettin' real jealous.
watch out tex is on the loose!
It's spring, Grace!
You more than anyone should know what that means!.....and flirting with you....... Hon, don't get me started!!!!
Nothing but love
Tex
Are you kidding? Tex is the
Are you kidding? Tex is the biggest flirt here. :) Hi Tex.
Hey now!
I thought I was special... thanks for the bubble burst.
:)
You ARE special.....and Tex is a big flirt. :)
Just one of the things we love about her.
Uh oh!!!
Looks like I've got overlapping flirting!
Nothing but love
Tex
Juniper......
..... I'll be up in Chicago before you know it, Hon!!!!
Nothing but love
Tex