Not a member? Join now
touch-upbanner image

The Thin Line Between Product Love and Hate

I know I promised Mouthal Care Part two for today, but something happened last weekend that begged for this... let’s call it an interlude.

What happened is that I got skunked. It’s a long story involving a runaway cat, a borrowed Havahartz and a gentleman from Animal Control who told me I had to deal with it myself unless I wanted them to confiscate the trap. Apparently you have to have a permit to attempt any Snoopy Come Home actions in Los Angeles. Curses!

I grouchily rinsed a third round of tomato sauce from my hair, thinking to myself for the 500th time how much I hate my shampoo and why do I still use it and grrr argh rarrrr blah. And then I considered its benefits... benefits enough to keep me buying it although the ledger is about even. And then I started thinking of other love/hate products. I had a long time to think about everything as I scrubbed and scrubbed.

Lush Daddy-O: It’s spendy as all fucking hell ($25 for a 500ml bottle) and it stinks like rancid violets. And yet, it is hands down the best color maintenance shampoo I have ever used, whether my hair is pink, blue, bleached, black or some variation on my natural brown. And it is concentrated, so that $25 goes pretty far. AND it nixed the residual skunk funk. This is seriously my ultimate push-pull product. Every time I finish one foul-smelling, expensive bottle, I vow to switch brands, then consider my fake hair color and turn right around to buy this again.

Vaseline: Is there anything it doesn’t do? It removes makeup, protects cuticles, hydrates ash, seals in moisture beneath lotion, smoothes chapped lips, makes an amazing overnight foot treatment, adds that healthy glow all over, lubes butt toys (or so they say)... and yet, the texture is just so... nasty. And it smells chemical, even the unscented stuff. The results are great, but the process? Lie back and think of England.

Mystery lipstick by Jordana, circa 1998 (?): This probably isn’t fair to include since it’s so old and I may actually have finally thrown it out, but this lipstick was my first love/hate product ever, so it’s getting commemorated regardless. The color is a gorgeous, deep brick with a satin finish. It’s versatile, neutral enough for work and saturated enough to just add gloss for playtime. But it sits in my lip creases like sediment and feathers way beyond my actual mouth, screaming “BEHOLD MY EVERY LINE!!!!!”

After my PQLP (Platonic Queer Life Partner) graciously smelled me to make sure the skunk was all gone, I mentioned my list to her, and she shared hers with me, so here I
share it with you:

Bare Minerals: Lucy calls it expensive, messy and time-consuming (it totally is). But “I look like an airbrushed movie stahh” (she totally does) and “it doesn’t piss off my very delicate epidermis” as long as she follows the directions to a T and cleans her brushes religiously.

The Verilux ClearWave Deluxe Acne Light: “It is surprisingly annoying to have to sit in front of a damn light for 15 minutes. It seems like an hour, I swear,” she says. But the results! She elaborates: “Vesuvius-sized eruptions are quickly tamed, red remnants of Vesuviuses past fade and my pores get all tight and perky. But seriously — 15 minutes in front of a light. I gave up tanning years ago, not just because I am paler than Lestat, but also because it was SO FREAKING ANNOYING to sit still doing NOTHING for so long.”

What about you guys? What are your love/hate products?

Stay beautiful and ambivalent,

--Chaia

22 Comments

Daddy-o

The thing I really don't get about Daddy-o is how ANYONE can think it smells good. It smells awful and in what I think is the latest catalogue produced by LUSH, they wrote that some people use. it. as. bodywash. And on MUA (makeupalley.com) and the LUSH website, there are people who write reviews that say it smells good. I just don't get it. How? Perhaps it's a batch-by-batch gamble as to whether you get fresh garden floral or artificial rancid garbage can floral.

Why don't they just call it like it is? They aren't afraid to mention that some of their other products smell less-than-awe-inducing, like the campfire solid shampoo.

I'm still working on my first bottle and I use it a couple times a week, interchanging it with Rehab, Karma Komba (solid) and New, which is also solid. Oh, and some Tresemme from a huge 1L bottle that cost me $4, and I quite enjoy it. Jury's still out on whether or not I'll get a second bottle of Daddy-o. It seems to be keeping the brass out of my very chemically blonde hair and leaves it feeling lovely, and luckily the scent doesn't stick for me.

Another borderline love/hate is Studio Fix Fluid. It is mostly a love love love. However, if I apply to much or haven't been altogether meticulous with my brush cleaning, it makes me look caked on dirty.

Glittery Nail Polish- basically any shade of any brand with chunks of sparkly material too big to be called shimmer. Why? Love because they're fun, hate because I have no idea what polish remover to use that actually gets it off with relative ease.

Cargo PlantLove Lipstick- I only have one shade, Lindsay Lohan, and it makes my lips basically peel. Like, if I exfoliate before applying it, my lips still somehow find extra skin that I didn't buff off. Why do I love it and want more colors? I love the color of LL, the tube is made of corn plastic which is cool, the box turns into wildflowers and two dollars from every purchase goes to St. Jude's. And I am a sucker.

Tarte's cheek stains. These fall into more of a "want to love, they look great and work great for others, why not me?" category, which I think is like the step-sibling to the love/hate category.

author

re: Vaseline

But it should work fine with silicone, no? I tend to use other stuff, hence the "so they say."

One word for all products...

Aveda

My chanel foundation - pro

My chanel foundation - pro lumiere number 10, and sometimes 20. I love it sometimes because it can make my skin glow when I'm having a bad skin day... but God its like $80 a bottle and sometimes its really not worth it.
Also my Evo shampoo and conditioner, its $29 a bottle and its really not all that special though it does smell deliscious. But I keep buying it because of the writing on the bottles! Together the shampoo and conditioner say: "Your hair is your friend, treat it right and you'll be on your way to mastering your destiny and becoming that person you always dreamed of being... Your hair is like a lover, ignore it and it will run off, shag our best friend and be sewing alfalfa sprouts into your new leather couch before you've had time to take your house keys back."

Haha, the writing lures me in everyyyyyyyy time.

author

I sooooo hear you on the

I sooooo hear you on the expensive foundation issue. I am psyching my bank account up to try Laura Mercier tinted moisturizer. We shall see how it goes. (And yeah, I can't escape the written text either!)

ok my love hates..

1. Axe. its a bitch to go buy when the lady behind the counters like "aw thats cute ur buying it for your boyfriend." um no
2. Head n Shoulders "cooling" ... keeps my hair clean and healthy ... but makes my eyes water..

on and the subject of vaseline... its skeeves me out! ky all the way.

"Heard they'd do anything for a klondike, Well I'd do anything for a blonde-dike." - kayne west [[stronger]]

editor

Other non-Vaseline uses...

Everyone should realize, since it's written right there on the label, that Vaseline is a petroleum-offshoot product. (You know petroleum. It's the stuff that powers your cars.) Besides that, using it on your lips actually interferes with your lips' ability to create their own moisture. This is true for Carmex, as well. It also shouldn't be used for fresh burns or nasal congestion.

My mother needs to know that

Kelly, I think my mother would be more receptive to this info coming from you than from me. I'll quote you next time I see her. :-)

I do use Vaseline sparingly.

I can't wait to tell my brother about this Vaseline conversation. He and I have joked for years about our mother's affinity for Vaseline.

I was following you

all the way up to PQLP...
does this mean you live together? share finances, do all the things habitating couples with LBD have but you don't worry about it because you are actually "Platonic?"

And was Plato really Platonic with all those young men..er...boys... or is that a misrepresentation of... shhh...gay?

As for Vasaline I use it to lube the plastic on my eye glasses. for all us 4 eyes, if you have plastic frames you know after like a year or so the plastic starts to dry out and make your frames look dull. a little vas and its all new.

And I'm with Madrilene on the lube the butt plug, I was always told never to use Vaseline?

author

pqlp

We do live together. We maintain separate(ish) finances and throw in our laundry together but refrain from bumping purses with each other. It's a good system for both of us although it probably wouldn't work for everyone.

I sincerely doubt Plato kept his hands to himself.

And, wait, with the Vaseline on the glasses - do you wash it off afterward? Or just rub it in? Do you rub it on the lenses or just the frames? (I am a four-eyes, as well.)

Thanks for the explanation

of pqlp. Good for you.:)

LOL

Thank you Grace. I had to stop and think and read the PQLP part over a few times.

it is the eleventh

it is the eleventh commandment
"you won't use Vaseline with Latex"

;-)

Vaseline Tip

Thanks, Madrilene. I won't let Vaseline or any other petroleum jelly product near my condoms. My mother didn't pass on that information to her children. :-)

Oops, this was supposed to be a reply to Madrilene down there.

lol near condom nor latex

lol
near condom nor latex sex toys, my mother said to me to tell you ;-)

Vaseline vs Windex

Vaseline helps in boxing matches and dry skin. But according to greek mythology, isn’t Windex the cure for all ailments? Whichever one would stop my dog from eyeballing me before pouncing my face, wins.

Honestly, I do not know the answer to the age-old question: Vaseline or Windex. Except to say that my grandmother’s mexican hot chocolate and homemade oatmeal makes me happy but that is neither here nor there.

“Can’t live without” girly list:
1.) Have very thick and long hair. Took a while to search but I fell in love with Jonathon Product shampoo & leave-in conditioner - best part, it’s vegan.
2.) Origins various facial products – too many to list
3.) Almond Oil Hand & Cuticle lotions from The Body Shop – does a great job. not thick or greasy so <3 it, just fabulous
4.) Rose Water lotion/soap/powder collection from Crabtree&Evelyn
5.) Nivea Crème
6.) Last, but not least: Necture, Blossom, and Honey cologne by Jo Malone

Hates:
Hmmm, can't think of any except ... wire hangers. NO WIRE HANGERS! Oh and Harry Potter Bertie Bott's Jelly Beans.

Peace & Love,
P~

No wire hangers

Cad, I am with you on that one. I go to Ikea to buy my wood hangers in bulk. Wood hangers are just better for clothing, like my jackets, which need more support than wire hangers can provide. I don't go all "Joan Crawford" about it though. Smile.

Vaseline

Chaia, my siblings and I used to joke about Vaseline because it was my Mother's all around answer to everything. But guess what I always had a jar of in my house since I've been an adult? Yep, Vaseline.

Hey, does anyone here use Bag Balm?

author

Seriously! I forgot to

Seriously! I forgot to mention that I use it to grease my cats' intestines when they have hairballs. A little smidge behind the front teeth and it's no more middle of the night hacking.

Bag balm

Minnie I use bag balm on the heels of my feet. I learned all about it's benefits from using it on teats.It keeps them soft,supple and prevents cracking.

Hi Minni and everybody,use

Hi Minni and everybody,
use Vaseline for everything EXCEPT to lube condom or sex toys in latex, it attacks it ! Use only lube with water often provided with condoms in gay places !

Yes, yes, yes!

Because Madrilene is right - it's a "No No!"

~paz y amor siempre