This is the third episode in our exclusive multi-part documentary series.
Don't miss
Part 1,
Part 2,
and our exclusive introductory sneak peek
slideshow of the documentary series.
CREDITS
MY ADDRESS: A Look At Gay Youth Homelessness
With Katherine Moennig
Director: Gigi Nicolas
Producer: Lindsay Webster
Editor: Carlos Almonte
Director of Photography: Vitaly Bokser
Second Camera: Hedia Maron
Location Audio: Joram Schwartz
Production Assistant: Tristan Cowen
Enormous thanks to the staff, board and young people of the Hetrick-Martin Institute who made this project a reality.
LEARN MORE
For more information about the Hetrick-Martin Institute, check out their website:
http://www.hmi.org/
For more information on the state of gay youth homelessness, check out the 2006 report issued by the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Policy Institute and the National Coalition for the Homeless:
http://www.thetaskforce.org/reports_and_research/homeless_youth
73 Comments
we really need places like
we really need places like this in orange county :/
.
very powerful
I could spend hours talking
I could spend hours talking about it cause I am catholic and I go through the same struggle.
But... I always try to see the good side of my religion and try not to feel angry about those crazy fanatic people....
It doesn't matter...
Where you came from, what you do, your color, your age, you sexual orientation. He loves us all. The problem is not God, on whatever religion, prejudice comes from people not from God. I find it cool, that even tho she suffered all that stuff from religious people she still believe in a higher power in her own way. That's important. To know you're being taken care of.
=)
Very nice editing on this one! And the questions were well done too!
xox
Christain
my friends mum is Christain but has loads of gay friends and knows my friends is bi and is fine with it!
Easy to relate to...
I was drawn to Nicole's story because I was raised in a strict religious home also. I realized in high school that I was attracted to girls but because of how I was raised I chalked it up to a phase or curiosity and continued to ignore who I truly was. I only came out to my mom and about 8 or so friends about 3 months ago because of my fear. I've always been unhappy but I didn't realize how unhappy I had been until I came out. It felt like a giant weight had been pulled off of my chest and even though I still worry about the rest of family's reactions I've never been happier. It's a relief when you let that door open and start to contemplate your life as the person you are not the person you were taught to be.
But anyways, good luck Nicole. You're awesome and strong and thanks for sharing your story.
My Catholic school feels small when I revisit it. Very, small.
Wow. Nicole is really coming along with herself. Seriously. I've never met anyone as grounded as her, despite her saying that she's still growing. She has definitely matured a *lot* because of her past experiences. I say, bravo, Nicole. Bravo.
I felt like I was sitting in the classroom with Nicole and Kate as they were discussing Nicole's experiences growing up in the Catholic faith. For me, growing up in my school from Kindergarten to the Eigth grade, homosexuality was never discussed. Or if it was, it was so forgettable that it must have only been one or two sentences mentioned. Ever.
I began to admit to myself I was gay in high school, and when I had discussions with my Christian friends asking them their thoughts, they immediately said that homosexuality was wrong and it says so in the bible. There was no way to get them to see that being gay wasn't wrong. I couldn't understand why it was so wrong because the subject was never talked about in school (that I can recall) and I was certainly never raised with preconceived biased notions of how to treat LGBTQ people. I was raised to treat everyone with equality and respect, because everyone is a human being.
So after talking with them, I started having doubts about myself and really hating the fact that I felt "this way" because God wouldn't love me for being a (at the time before admitting I was a lesbian) bisexual. I was convinced my parents would kick me out of the house, I thought I was the most foul and disgusting disease to exist on God's green earth. It felt like the church and God's eyes were staring right at me and pointing, telling me I was an abomination.
My faith slowly started dying, and it became damn near obliterated because of a few family members passing away so suddenly, mixed in further with my trying to love myself as a lesbian from a traditional Vietnamese Catholic family surrounding (and I'm also bi-racial). Now that I've separated myself a little bit from living with my parents, and building myself by being surrounded with friends and family I care about who are teaching me to love myself, I feel slightly more secure. Even though my dad disagrees with my being gay, he says that God loves everyone no matter what, and that I'm not condemned in His eyes. So...now I've started developing my own relationship with Him. I've been finding out who God is to me just through the people I've met who show that loving yourself first cycles good karma and at the end of the day you feel really, really good.
Great last question. "When
Great last question. "When you look at your future what do you see?" It must be tremendously hard to have high goals without support. But it is still important to be ambitious and strong when society pushes you down.
3 2 1 ...take off!
is just amazing!....
`when I came out to my mum was hard..even I believe she went to take me out of the house but she didn`t..but is like she did i don`t have her support sometimes and is lil hard..so can`t imagine well how this teens feels but know there are people helping and supporting them...is great what they do.....
Struggle with being gay and having faith
When I was outed to my parents about 6 or 7 years ago, it was really hard for me. My parents are conservative southern baptists. They didn't want a gay person in their house. So, I moved in with my girlfriend at the time, and then she kicked me out because i was struggling with my faith. So, i was homeless for a while. It was hard knowing that family and faith gave up on me. At this point, I gave up everything I was taught about religion and faith. And went to college as a religion/philosophy major. There I formed a new relationship with God and beliefs. A lot were the same as I was taught, except for certain things. God still loves me. I just have to reach out to Him again. He never left. At times I still struggle, but if it weren't for that, where would my strength be, right? :)
† amg1281@gmail.com †
Thanks so much for the video
Thank you Kate for shedding light on homelessness in the GLBTQ community. I was not homeless as a child but knew first hand how having religious parents can effect your psychic escpecially if that religion bashing gay people. I was devastated as a young person to know that God could not possible love me because I was Gay eventhough I had such love for him. Thanks to the Metropolitian Community Church (prenominately gay church) I found my way back to God. Not that i ever lost him but my heart had been reconciled back to him. For those of you looking for a relationship with God, a personal relationship is the only way to know God plan for your life and trust God always. His will be done.
Nicole
Sad, but true. I lost faith when I came out, but then I realized, God is love, and the bible is just a book. God doesn't hate you for loving someone, he love you. I think when he looks at all the children Gay Straight Trans Bi and other, he looks at them with pride. Too bad humans aren't as compassionate as God is. This world would be a better place. Nicole. Hang in there honey. Everyone else. Keep talking to the God of your understanding to help all the children. Cause the truth is, today you are only hearing about some of the kids who made it. Not the ones who didn't.
Peace, Love and Hope people.
I was homeless for years
I was homeless in Los Angeles when I was a teen. I left home when I was 14. I remember doing things to survive that I would rather forget. I slept in allies and ate old burgers that McDonalds had thrown out in the trash. I put myself in the position to be abused often. Depression and fear was always present, although I never showed it. I appeared strong and happy, especially if I lucked out and could get high. .
I'm sure they had shelters back then for teens (I'm in my 40's), but I didn't know anything about them, if I had, I probably would have been afraid they would send me back home anyway, or worse, condemn me for being who I am (a lesbian) which is why I left home in the first place. I did what I had to do to get by, I don't regret my choice. However, I do hope things get a little easier for those teens that are still out there today. Kate has the power to make a change...I am very appreciative that she has decided to exercise her power in this way.
P.S. I have a wonderful life today, a life most would envy.
I got lucky, most homeless teenagers aren't so lucky. I'm only telling my story so that some of you who don't know what it is like to be a child, and homeless can better grasp the importance in the work that Kate is doing. Homeless children live with their mental scars forever.
byteofpride.com
Thank you for sharing byteofpride
Thank you for sharing your story, i cnt even imagine what it must've been like all those years ago! All i can say is that ur story is inspiring and it takes a lot to talk about it. So thank you.
But the way i think about it is that for these kids there's still room to grow and to be what they wanna be, so if they're not accepted by their familiese thay can seperate their way and to make their own family and explore the world of being gay without their support and undrestanding.
But there are some countries in the world that not even the law supports homosexual kids or adults not to mention what their own families do to them. So basically there are places in the world that the government executes and kills homosexuals whose sexuality is revealed in the name of law and religion and nothing is done.
It makes me so fucking angry just typing about it...
............................
We start kissing and we can't stop kissing!
These keep getting better :)
I’m still trying to find the words.
Nicole--- never stop growing and never stop searching to understand your relationship (your faith)—it’s journey. You are mature and probably more then your friends whom you grew up with. I’m a mother and you make me proud to see the younger generation as being capable of deeper things. I know there are a lot of youth that go in to deep reflection and search, but to see it—is like hearing of a good deed.
I see a bright future for you. And knowing where you have been and what you have been through, I would not be surprised if you ended up working with kids and social work. You have an advantage. Your smart, caring, you have empathy—and you been there. I wish the best! :)
Wow, these segments are really defining. It’s true though, if parents turn their backs and the system has cracks and those who want to help, but can’t because funds are exhausted—who does help guide these young adults?
rovermom :)
Life is a 3D puzzle and everyone has a piece! :)
Fuckin' totally here, here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Fuckin' totally here, here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You are so spot on. Nichole is a lovely chick, & so are other amazing individuals, & that's what they are, SO, SO, SMART, SO SWEET, SO VULNERABLE, & yet so STRONG!!!!!! Oh man, wicked!!!!!!!!!!
gay, homeless youth project
What an utterly astounding project with a topic that has remained unchartered until now. I would really love to know the statistics on the numbers of gay homeless youth as opposed to all other types of youth to see the over representation of homelessness for gay teens.
Kudos to Kate for taking on this wonderful project of a much ignored population and giving them a voice.
EXTRA
thank you for this sort of intimate episode. Nicole, just stay who you are, a person proud to be gay with this god with you.
And Kate, incredible pictures !!!
keep smiling
Much Love
Nicole i cried watching this....from your pal jamelia
now we are going to go to the d^ke march
J.A.J.M
Nicole you are so brave!!!!
Nicole you are the bravest angel xxx
This episode really touched me, actually. Being Catholic Vs Being gay.
I used to think I had something to be ashamed of. It took me a long time to find God again. To separate the vatican and their obsession of power and real God who just said love everyone and yourself and be happy...lol
For the record, the word 'homosexuality' does not exist in the original Bible. And there are actually 3 gay couples in the Bible.
For more info see:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_bmar.htm
just G R E A T !!!!
just a great job from kate....just be PROUD TO BE GAY!!!....go KATE go...we love u....thats the best documentary i ever seen from the best person KATE...
You've got me hooked.
You've got me hooked to this documentary , Its incredible. I always thought I had it hard but this really shows how hard it is for some people to just feel accepted and to be accepted , because of this documentary I'm starting a GLBT youth support group here in shanghai China or at least I'm trying to. The government here can be very un-corruptive.
Thanks for doing this kate!
your truly amazing
and also thanks to the director Gigi Nicolas and the rest of the crew.
Raven
My few words :)
FAN-TAS-TIC documentary part.
Nicole you're great woman.
And for Kate....i don't have words :)
"Me"
The Best Yet....
This installment is the best one yet. And I think that, not only because it is my story, but because so many of us identify with this young lady. My religous upbringing has always been the number 1 thing that has held me back from coming out.
Kate, I can not begin to express how much respect & admiration I have for you for bringing this problem to light. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Can't wait to see the rest.
Eye Opening~
Hi Everyone!
Im so new to tis, happpen to chance upon the videos of gay homelessness.
Where i came from in Asia, these issues are always so closeted.
Im just glad i found ourchart.com
Oh Yeah.....
Oh yeah, thanks a whole bunch Kate for even doing something like this. I know that you already have and will continue to help so many gay youth. Again, thank you Kate!
Ms.Dee a.k.a. Daddy'sGirl
Wow!!!
I was sooooo moved by Nicole's story. She is incrediblely strong, and is still just in high school. It really opens your eyes to the real world and how discriminating some people can be. I too am gay, and I too was raised in a very religious family, but I have not yet built up the nerve to tell my parents who I really am. I am a 22 year old college senior, and still afraid. This story is a real inpiration for me. It makes me feel like I can tell my parents and still be okay with myself and with God. My mother, like Nicole's mother will probably not try to understand or even try to listen. My dad on the other hand, may try to listen and understand where I am coming from. We have always been extremely close. I think that I will tell my dad first, and then maybe he can help me tell my mother. Wish me luck!
Ms.Dee a.k.a. Daddy'sGirl
homosexuality and religion
homosexuality and religion is such an interesting subject 2 me. eye grew up in a religious family as well. as a kid, eye went 2 catholic school, church every sunday, the whole 9 yards. in my teens, eye realized eye was gay. everyone who has ever told me that god condemns me bcuz of who eye am defends their assertation the same way: the bible says so. "the bible is very clear about homosexuality," they'll argue. eye'm older and wiser now. the minute anyone uses the bible 2 defend hate a warning light goes off. similar arguments have been used by racists, anti-semites and sexists the world over.
eye've read the bible from cover 2 cover enuff times 2 know what it really has 2 say about homosexuality. the answer: not a whole lot. the truth is: the bible has very little 2 say on the subject. the ten commandments completely overlook it and jesus himself never mentions it. yet, "christians" continue 2 wave their "god hates fags" signs, claiming they r "fighting 4 their god." actually, all they r doing is fighting against their brothers and sisters.
"christians" will say that god created adam and eve, not adam and steve. the fact is: a race needed 2 b started and perpetuated. so, god created man and woman and he required both 4 procreation. the story of creation is merely the beginning of mankind, not the end, not the xtent. relationships solely 4 the purpose of procreation r no longer necessary. consider friendship. consider celibacy. consider the single state. no stigma is attached 2 any of these. celibates r not condemned. singles r not labeled "sick." yet, gay people r reminded daily of our "doomed fate." such selective interpretation of the word is abuse of scripture.
the story of sodom and gomorrah is often cited 2 support god's stance against homosexuality. many "christians" will say god destroyed sodom bcuz it was a city full of sin, and that sin was homosexuality. if the bible was read without one's own hateful agenda, it would b apparent that sodom was destroyed bcuz its citizens were xtremely inhospitable. their intent 2 rape the angels who came 2 visit their city characterized them as wicked. thus, sodom earned its destruction NOT bcuz its people displayed same sex affection, but bcuz they displayed NO affection at all.
leviticus 18:22 says: "thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is abomination." in most cases in the bible where the word "abomination" is used the reference is 2 something that is ritually impure as opposed 2 something inherently evil like child abuse, rape or murder. homosexuality is no more abominable than working on the sabbath, having sex with a woman during her period, having a clean-shaven face, eating pork or shellfish, having a tattoo or wearing clothes that r made from a blend of textiles. all of these things were considered "abominations" as they went against the ritual beliefs of israel at that time. show me one "christian" who has worked on the weekend, eaten a hot dog, gotten a tattoo, worn polyester-cotten blends or shaved and eye'll show u a hypocrite.
in paul's letter 2 the romans he seems 2 b condemning homosexual acts. but, what xactly was he referring 2? was he talking about pederasty? was he talking about homosexual acts committed with slaves? was he talking about homosexual acts connected with idolatry? we simply do not know. he seemed 2 think homosexuality was synonymous with avarice, lust, and xploitation. what he failed 2 realize tho was that homosexual relationships did xist that involved monogamy, respect, honor and love. rape, abuse and murder r not unheard of in heterosexual marriages or relationships. 2 judge all heterosexuals based upon what we c on the 11 o'clock news is just as ridiculous as judging all homosexuals based on paul's limited xperience some 2000 years ago.
many "christians" will continue 2 use the bible 2 support their own hatred of homosexuals/homosexuality. the bible is not the problem. the problem lies with the "christians" who r reading it. "a new commandment eye give un2 u, that ye love one another; as eye have loved u, that ye also love one another. by this shall all men know that ye r my disciples, if ye have love one 2 another." ironically, instead of being synonymous with love, hate has become the most common word associated with the "christian right" 2day.
it's time 4 us 2 look at one another and perceive love. we r all in this 2gether. when asked outright about the greatest commandment, jesus simply said: "thou shalt love the lord thy god with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. this is the first and great commandment. and the second is like un2 it, thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." he did not say "hate thy neighbor" or "condemn" or "judge" or "shun" or even "tolerate" him. he said "LOVE."
and on that note, eye'd like 2 say: nicole, if u're out there reading this: u r a beautiful child of god. stand strong and proud. god LOVES u... and so do eye!
It is so crazzzy
I use to be in a very strict church when I was younger. I left the church a few years ago and came out about a year or so later. I still have friends in the church and I just got off the phone with one of them before I logged online and you post and this installment by Kate has help me so much. My friend was just telling me how I am an abomination and that I am worse that your average unsaved person because I knew the truth and then turned to homsexuality. She told me that Satan has a strong hold on me and that when I am ready to be saved it may be to late because God may not allow my salvation because of my actions. When I hear all this as I frequently do, it is hard at times for me not to question God's view or love for me. Thanks to this post and this installment I at least temporarily feel relief.
It's so unfair
I think that as catholic and tolerant person you cann't judge, because any religion give you the right to select or approve who deserves love or who doesn't. Five years ago I find myself so desesperate and alone but I can tell you that God didn't let me alone.It's right that I left some friendships but I get new and stronger ones.
saved
many people will tell us that the only way we can b saved is 2 renounce our homosexuality. that is very much AT ODDS with what the bible says. according 2 the bible there is only ONE requirement 4 being saved.
4 god so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 4 god sent not his son in2 the world 2 condemn the world; but that the world thru him might b saved. he that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, bcuz he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten son of god. (john 3:16-18)
simply put, it does not matter if one is gay or straight, male or female, black or white. all that matters, according 2 the bible, is that one believes in jesus christ.
our "friends", parents, or priests might try 2 convince us that as long as we r gay god will reject us. jesus himself sets the record straight: "whoever comes 2 me eye will never drive away." (john 6:37) "whoever" is a beautiful word in that it does not xclude ANYONE, rather it includes EVERYONE!
please do not let anyone take ur god away from u.
i agree
I so agree on this topic you are so right finally someone who knows their stuff and you know what i hope you know you answered alot of my questions, and im sure you will answer nicoles to thanks and peace.
'
'
Amazing
This is an amazing project. I think that it is important to show others what some gay youth go through and their struggles. It makes me greatful for the family and friends that I have that accepted me for who I am. I couldn't imagine living on the streets because of my sexuality. My heart goes out not only to those kids, but to anybody that is afraid to be who they are.
WOW
How empowering is this to watch. Kate Kudo's to you and all the kids living in this hellish part of life.
this one
Especially got to me because I am fairly religious and struggled with a lot of the issues involved with the church and God when things were first happening with she and I. I asked myself many of the same questions. Like how is it that God loves everyone, but hates me for this one thing. How can God love molesters and killers and those people are able to be forgiven, but just because I'm gay God hate me no matter what. Makes no sense.
http://www.hrc.org
My heart goes to this project
Amazing! Applause to this project and to the people behind this project. Nicole is truly a unique and touched individual. Her story and her strength has and will open a lot of minds and hearts, and maybe even invoke change.I could understand Nicole’s hesitation about admitting who she was at first. The hardest thing to accept is change. But it is even harder (and at the same time admirable) to admit that change, and accepting yourself as being gay or just plain different. These kids who have come out and faced life's cruelty are remarkable creatures. They may be even more blessed by GOD than any other one of His/Her creations.
______________________________________________________________
If only this was a perfect world, then we can see Shane and Carmen together again...sigh!
Eye Opening...
These episodes have really made me aware of a growing epidemic that I guess I was blind to before. I wish more people could see these kids. Thanks Kate (assuming you read this) for opening our eyes to a truly tragic problem. I'm a little low on money right now, but I just donated to the LBGT fund and I think everyone else should too... every little bit counts.
So interesting
Relgion is always a slippery slope, who is to say what is right or so called wrong in the world. Everybody has the right to find and live their way in life without fear. Its just really sad that it is not always the case. Nicole seems so strong and intelligent fantastic.
'sometimes nothing makes sense and everything seems so far away'
I hope that Nicole gets her
I hope that Nicole gets her faith back. Religion is not about living by a book (written by a man) it is about believing in a higher power. The church changes every so often to suit the people. Rules that were made by the church years ago have now been changed to suit the people of today. Nicole should feel that God is always on her side. He is inside her. Christians believe that God created the world, man and animals. All species of animals interact sexually with male and females of the species. It's how they were created. So why do people belive that it is wrong for humans to interact this way. Do they believe that God created us all but will discriminate against humans for doing this when he created animals to do the same thing. For me it's people and not God who has the problem with this. I hope Nicole realises how strong she is.
i agrree with you,i'm not
i agrree with you,i'm not into religion, i don't believe in god ,but i think that this is what people /not god /can't accept, i mean gay people,you know they are so afraid of something diferent..but what is worst that maybe some of them are ok with that,they accept you for who you are,but they are afraid of what the others who can't accept that think about them,yeah people are hard about that
love
i detest religion. how many people have to go through this torture? and for what? it's the most absurd thing ever.
Gigi Nicolas,
Gigi Nicolas,
Gigi, you are a very good director and story teller,
Well done!
Kate Moennig
She is amazing and yet giving!! I am really glad when I see famous people do something positive in the world. Not just put their faces and give money but actually physically and mentally get involved with such an amazing project.
Thanks Kate!!
xoxo
question : if GOD love
question : if GOD love killers and rapers then why cant he love gays????
so is it really GOD tht doesnt or is it the fear of those representing him that are afraid to love the unconventional?
are they the true representatives or are they the manipulators ?
pppffftss so much more to shout at but there is no point coz if everyone reach into their own soul they will realised tht GOD is in them and not out there controlling them........then perhaps we will align our heart and soul and do the good things and the right things
oh my God ?
Yes sure
may i adress a question about religion : here in France we used to have a laic, secularity tradition, and i understand that the purpose of this documentary is to make portrait of individuals, but it's quite weird for me (who don't believe GOD exist i must admit) to see first place religion is here taken. I know the point of view is to show the rejecting process acting even in a church that should shelter.
But for me faith in regilion will not necessary make the civil rights and trust in oneself go forward for gays ! It's sometime also a political way to neutralize and divide people under an ideologic smoke screen. I hope we will also see portraits without God as guest star ;-)
(don't misunderstand what i say, i do respect believers but till their faith is private)
God!
My true thought on god not loving gays, is impossible.How can he not love someone for being born a certain way?That,s like saying he does,nt love certain races,because they were born that way,it just could not be.
this episode left me sad bc
this episode left me sad bc of the situation i'm in.
i dunno what else to write.
being gay and religion
My hats are off to you Nicole, your so strong and you will find so much happiness. I also know whats its like to be gay and have a strong faith in my family. I am a 31 year old single mom and just told my mom that I was gay. (She is a Mormon). Just think how that went!!!! So I do understand how hard it is to feel the feeling you feel and wonder if god still loves you or not.
Kate your were very cute as a child, I too had a awkward stage but you were too cute. Nicole was a very cute kid too. Please keep up the good work Kate it is amazing.
xxooxx to you both
This is so powerful
This is ... powerful, important and needs more attention.
I just have no words at the moment. I would like to see this these episodes as a DVD and with a thirty dollar donation to HMI maybe we could get one :)
Just an idea :)
hugs